I actually question how useful right-to-carry would be in the Garden State, when pretty regularly you see people defending themselves getting into trouble with the law. This Jersey City gun shop owner had some words with individuals who were blocking him in double parking. Not the wisest thing to do if you’re armed, but that doesn’t excuse beating someone to the ground.
Not long after, his store had a gun stolen, and officials used that as an excuse to pull his license, and not longer after that he was facing felony charges. Hudson County prosecutors got not only one grand jury to indict the guy, but two, after the initial charges were thrown out after it was shown the prosecution lied about the gun shop owner not having a license for the gun.
What’s wrong with people in New Jersey? I’ll be the first to admit that confronting the double parking vehicle wasn’t the smartest thing to do. Once the situation escalated, the smart thing to do was to retreat and call the police. But you don’t get to beat a man when he’s down on the ground. I might, as a juror, consider charges of simple assault for the both of them, and I’d probably even accept a charge for firing the gun within city limits. But a felony gun charge, when the guy is licensed to carry? No way. It looks like he got off with probation, but he’s still a convicted felon:
A former Jersey City gun store owner who fired into the air while he was apparently being attacked outside a Downtown club two years ago was sentenced today to two years probation and 100 hours of community service and ordered to undergo anger management counseling.
So he gets sentenced as if it were a simple assault, which at worst it was, since it depends on who’s story you believe as to whether he was a willing participant in the fight. But it doesn’t, to me, appear that Mr. Murray asked to be beaten.