McCain did himself a favor when he selected Palin as his running mate. The base immediately fell in love with her, but the subsequent media lynching, I think, subdued the enthusiasm, particularly on the heels of some poorly thought out interviews she pretty clearly wasn’t ready for. I think the base still adores Palin, but she needs to gain a bit more expeirence under her belt before she returns to national politics.
You can blame Bush for this one, but Republicans, and center-right Independents have spent the last eight years having to carry the White House’s water on the Iraq War, because the White House was not able to competently handle mistakes, missteps, and difficulties. We also spent the past eight years watching a President not only fail to articulate and make the case for conservative values, but one who wouldn’t deliver them either.
But McCain’s biggest gaffe, I think, was in the debates. The debates were all scripted talking points, which tended to work in Obama’s favor. Obama is comfortable when he’s able to work off of talking points. Conservatives wanted to see McCain go after Obama, articulate against his policies, and make the case for conservatism. I think McCain largely failed on that count, and not in a small way. Conservatives, faced with the prospect of another soft, inarticulate candidate, seem to have decided to stay home in relatively large numbers this election. The next Republican candidate will need to be able to carry the message. Obama is popular among the left and center-left because he can do that with great skill. Reagan was popular for largely similar reasons. I have to wonder how many conservatives actually saw McCain as just another inarticulate non-conservative, and decided to stay home.