Another Round of Good News for Us, Bad News for Bloomberg

On Friday morning, I noticed that the little counter on the MAIG website had Bloomberg’s numbers down to 400 mayors. Meanwhile, the news release touting more than 450 mayors was running on the website. (Apparently they haven’t discovered the memory hole, even though this would be an appropriate use for it.) Later that day, after more mayors were scrubbed, Sebastian noted that they removed the counter completely so you can no longer easily count the number of mayors in their organization. All of this happened after they removed their handy map and moved a request to join to the top of the home page.

So with all of the changes that Bloomberg is so desperate to hide, let’s do a survey of where we stand in the effort to oust mayors from anti-gun coalition:

NRA’s Postcard Mailing
NRA sent a postcard to members in select cities of MAIG coalition members in Pennsylvania and around the country. They set up a corresponding website and interactive map inspired by our use of the same type of map for Pennsylvania. We did directly contribute to quite a bit of research on mayors nationwide, but especially on Pennsylvania mayors based on information uncovered while doing the long series of initial Bloomberg posts.

Obviously, as the 800 lb. gorilla, their mailing has generated many media hits and direct pressure on mayors around the state. Reports range from anecdotal stories of small town mayors swamped by angry residents wondering what the hell they have been doing to small town mayors facing censure votes for making their town look anti-gun to NRA members simply giving up and not even picking up the phone. Some good, some awesome, and some sad.

PAFOA’s Educational Outreach
Shortly after the Bloomberg series of posts, Pennsylvania Firearms Owners Association wrote to 15 mayors the organization thought they might be able to influence informing them of positions taken in their name and politely asking the mayors to resign from Bloomberg’s coalition. This morning PAFOA decided to turn up the pressure and asked their local members to call their mayors and again ask for their resignation. While the organization is not as large as NRA, it is full of activists who are more likely to be inspired to act quickly on the hells of success in other towns.

So where to do we stand as we head into this next round of taking out Bloomberg’s power structure in Pennsylvania?

  • On August 17, I reported there were 103 mayors in Pennsylvania who were members of MAIG.  We’re now down to 87.  Fifteen of those mayors left by resigning from the organization and one died.
  • In the same post, I asked: “Do you think the 684 residents of Ulysses know that Mayor Jane Haskins was campaigning against concealed carry and has supported lawsuits that put gun shops out of business?”  Mayor Haskins was among the first to leave the organization after the NRA postcards landed in her town.
  • I also noted a geographical surprise: “It might surprise people to see that most of the mayors who support Michael Bloomberg are not in the Philadelphia suburbs. In fact, 32% of the mayors are in far western Congressional districts.”  The statistical breakdown runs just about the same.  Only 25% of the mayors who have departed the organization were from those far west Congressional districts.  If they convince more mayors to leave, then we’ll have a more expected spread.
  • In August, the number of residents reached by Mayor Mike’s message was 2,899,142.  We’ve cut that down more than 33,000.  (Half of that number is Philadelphia alone.  The other big contributer is Pittsburgh.  It would be tough to convince either mayor to leave.  So a drastic change won’t likely happen with this statistic.)
  • The following day, I mentioned that Pennsylvania is the largest source of mayors for the anti-gun crusade.  “If he has at least 450 mayors, that means 23% of them are from Pennsylvania!”  Even reduced to 87, with all of the other mayors flocking to leave the coalition, we still have 22% here in Pennsylvania.  That’s disappointing, but it is a very small dent that we’ll keep working to make bigger.
  • I also mentioned that nine mayors have pushed illegal preemption-violating local gun ordinances have been members of MAIG.  Unfortunately, I don’t have great news to report on this front.  The York mayor who is proudly standing by Bloomberg pushed through a resolution supporting one gun a month in Pennsylvania after this campaign started.  However, this does reiterate that we need to reduce Bloomberg’s numbers to keep his influence minimal.

So overall, we’re not doing too badly.  However, there is still a lot of room for improvement.  By far, Pennsylvania has more mayors than any other state.  And if gun owners here don’t get active, they will lose their rights.  This is just one move, but it’s disabling what Bloomberg has envisioned as the future of the gun control movement.  We might as well make him a political liability and cut this thing off at the knees, so-to-speak.

For those who wonder about the PA mayors who have left, here’s the latest list:

  • Akron Mayor John McBeth
  • Beech Creek Mayor David E. Orr
  • Bowmanstown Mayor Keith G. Billig
  • Brackenridge Mayor Jeffrey Cowan
  • East Berlin Mayor Keith Hoffman
  • Gettysburg Mayor William Troxell
  • Harmony Mayor Cathryn H. Rape
  • Midway Mayor Karen Bartosh
  • Mt. Penn Mayor Josh Nowotarski
  • North Irwin Mayor Leonard L. Santimyer
  • Slatington Mayor Walter Niedermeyer
  • Summit Hill Mayor Paul R. McArdle
  • Tower City Mayor Dale Deiter
  • Ulysses Mayor Jane Haskins
  • West Reading Mayor Shane Keller

If your town or boro is on this list, please take a moment to call your mayor and say thank you.

Arlen Apparently Not Keen on NRA Grade

Here’s the vote breakdown on the Amtrak bill.  Senator Specter was among the no votes, along with a lot of other Democrats.  Keep in mind this is a bill so modest, even the Brady Campaign doesn’t have a problem with it.  No Republican voted against it.

I think it’s safe to say that Arlen Specter’s NRA grade is toast this election.  I hope, in fact, that NRA will endorse his opponent.

Corbett Announces

I’m a few days late on this one, but Corbett is officially in the race now, running against 6th District Congressman Jim Gerlach.  I have nothing against Gerlach as a Congressman, but I’ll be honest, his candidacy for Governor never really made that much sense to me.  Corbett has a track record of being able to win state wide elections, even in years where it’s tough to be a Republican.  Gerlach is giving up his previously very tightly contested Congressional seat, meaning the GOP is going to have to pour money and resources into that district in order to keep it.

I understand politicians are ambitious, and Governor is an easier step to the Oval Office than Congress or Senate, but I think Gerlach is unlikely to capture the nomination. Still, Gerlach has a track record of winning tough elections too, so he is probably not to be underestimated. It should be an interesting race.

PA Mayors Leaving Bloomberg’s Group

This is a cross posting from PAGunRights.com of the most up-to-date information I can find about the Pennsylvania mayors who are leaving MAIG. My reference to local here is anything the 8th, 13th, or 19th districts since those are the areas covered by the site contributors.

A roar of protest is spreading among Pennsylvania mayors who are rejecting New York City-style gun control and leaving Mayor Bloomberg’s anti-gun group. His Pennsylvania coalition once numbered 103 mayors, and in a matter of weeks, it has fallen to only 91. With help from gun owners who are willing to pick up the phone to protect their rights, we can reduce that number even more.

One report from a mayor claimed that she was called by nearly a dozen gun owners during her lunch hour on the day NRA notifications reached mailboxes. She quickly called to resign from the group, leading the still-rising wave of resignations of Pennsylvania mayors.


View Bloomberg’s Anti-Gun Mayors in Pennsylvania in a larger map

As you can see, mayors who have recently left the group include:

  • Akron Mayor John McBeth
  • Beech Creek Mayor David E. Orr
  • Bowmanstown Mayor Keith G. Billig
  • Harmony Mayor Cathryn H. Rape
  • Mount Penn Mayor Josh Nowotarski
  • North Irwin Mayor Leonard L. Santimyer
  • Summit Hill Mayor Paul R. McArdle
  • Tower City Mayor Dale Deiter
  • Ulysses Mayor Jane Haskins
  • West Reading Mayor Shane Keller

Unfortunately, some mayors are making their position against lawful gun owners clear and standing by Mayor Bloomberg’s efforts to restrict concealed carry licenses and sue gun stores out of business. York’s John Brenner says he plans to continue his membership and proudly cites his support for eradication of statewide preemption by passing illegal local gun control ordinances. Sadly, the only NRA members featured in the story said they were not willing to make the phone call to demand their mayor stand up for the Second Amendment.

In addition to Mayor Brenner, these local mayors have refused to resign from the group:

  • Ambler Mayor Charles T. “Bud” Wahl
  • Carlisle Mayor Kirk R. Wilson
  • Doylestown Mayor Libby White
  • East Berlin Mayor Keith E. Hoffman
  • Gettysburg Mayor William E. Troxell
  • Hatboro Mayor Norm Hawkes
  • Mount Wolf Mayor James F. Kinder
  • Philadelphia Mayor Michael Nutter
  • Telford Mayor Jay Stover
  • Windsor Mayor Larry Markel

Let’s make sure that NRA members, gun owners, and hunters in these towns are willing to pick up the phone or even send an email in defense of their rights.

Since our update last week, NRA-ILA has launched a detailed webpage to keep gun owners updated on the status of mayors in the anti-gun coalition. The site is a tool to compliment the recent postcard mailings sent to gun owners around the country. You can find not only the current list of mayors, but also mayors who have quit the organization, MAIG members who are not actually mayors as advertised, mayors who recently lost elections, and MAIG members who are currently facing charges or have been convicted of various crimes ranging from assault to corruption.

Patrick Murphy: Arrogant Bastard

For a second term Congressman, Patrick Murphy is one arrogant bastard. While he did win his last race handily and is a very successful fundraiser, the more stories of his absolute disrespect of residents come out, the less important money and past performance will be in future races. When it comes down to votes, constituents who actually show up to the polls don’t like this form of arrogance.

Take, for example, his refusal to do town hall meetings. He’ll claim he did have town hall meetings, but only because citizens crashed his private meetings and demanded he open the doors. He absolutely will not listen to residents with concerns, and there are numerous reports that he won’t answer questions. During a so-called town hall meeting, rather than talking to constituents, he decided to take time for an interview with a left-wing organization in DC where he explained that as a Congressman, it is his duty to explain to residents what is best for them. Funny that most citizens, regardless of political affiliation, would consider it your job to STFU and listen to them.

After being called on to host town halls, Murphy told the local media he would do it – on the day that many regional government health care opponents would be in DC. Except one new upstart group of citizen activists wasn’t too confident in that claim given his past performance. A few phone calls to the owners of the restaurants where the town halls were scheduled confirmed the suspicion. It turns out Patrick Murphy quickly canceled the town hall events.

As if that isn’t enough arrogance, he won’t even send staff in to do the dirty, lowly work of talking with the residents of his district. When the Thomas Jefferson Club organized their own health care forum when Murphy refused to host one in the district, they reached out to him with an invitation. Patrick Murphy decided a DC fundraiser was more important, but at least agreed to send a staffer to represent him. Except when more than 300 constituents turned out last night to hear from their Congressman’s staff member, they found he/she was a no-show.

To their credit, this new organization here in Bucks County really seems to be capitalizing on the discontent, and based on the events we have attended with organizers, it is clearly not an off-shoot of the local GOP. I don’t know if the GOP could turn out these kinds of results. 300+ to a health care town hall on a Tuesday night. More than 100 attended a general meeting in August, up from 50+ in July. This is the organization that developed out of the highly successful Bucks County Tea Party we attended in April. These folks are really taking it to the next level and turning the energy and passion into something useful. Perhaps if the GOP can find a quality candidate, we can show Patrick Murphy what arrogance in politics buys you – a one-way ticket home.

More Mayor Updates

As updated on PAGunRights.com, there have been a few members dropping out of the Bloomberg coalition over recent days. Specifically, two mayors in Pennsylvania have removed themselves from the coalition and another member passed away in recent days. While it would have been nice to change the mind of the mayor of State College who recently passed due to complications from surgery, we can at least celebrate the opening of minds of the mayors of Ulysses and Summit Hill.


View Bloomberg’s Anti-Gun Mayors in Pennsylvania in a larger map

Non-Pennsylvania losses also include:
Mayor Jerry Taylor of Boynton, FL
Mayor Linda Riner-Mizell of Dundee, FL
Mayor Mark Hawke of Gardner, MA
Mayor A.J. Holloway of Biloxi, MS
Mayor Jim Bouley of Concord, NH (New Hampshire’s only mayor on the list!)
Mayor Dale Strasser of Brunswick, OH
Mayor Kathy Taylor of Tulsa, OK
Mayor Thomas M. Taylor of Franklin, WI
Mayor James Schmitt of Green Bay, WI
Mayor Dave Ross of Superior, WI

Web Site Fail

From Capitol Ideas:

Looks Like Rep. Doug Reichley …
… may have a challenger in 2010. Patrick Slattery, a health care industry worker from Lower Macungie Twp. in Lehigh County, writes this morning to let us know he’s decided to throw his hat into the ring for next year’s contest in the 134th House District.
A look at Mr. Slattery’s campaign Web page reveals that he has a wife, family and an MBA. He also goes to church and appears to be active in environmental causes. Annoyingly, however, neither the Web site nor his press release make any mention of whether he’s a Republican or Democrat.
In the absence of such information, we’re pleased to inform the voters of the 134th District that Mr. Slattery will be the first Bull Moose candidate since 1912. So please join us in a hearty welcome to the state’s newest Bull Moose candidate. We’re glad to have you back.

You know, given how both the Republicans and Democrats have been performing, I have to wonder if this is actually fail, or a brilliant campaign strategy.

Not So Popular Now, Eh?

Apparently sixty eight percent of Pennsylvanians don’t think our Guv is doing that great a job:

Sixty-eight percent of those surveyed say the two-term Democrat is doing a fair or poor job, compared to 29 percent who gave him a good or excellent rating. That’s an historic low for Rendell.

I almost get the feeling Rendell stopped trying after he got reelected.  After 2006, and after a huge defeat of Lynn Swann, he figured he didn’t have to work to please anyone, or worry about pissing voters off royally.   Now that rooster is coming home to roost.  If I were a Democratic hopeful for the Governor’s seat in 2010, I’d be more than a bit unhappy with Rendell’s behavior.  Pennsylvania has oscillated back and forth between Democratic and Republican governors since World War II.  Rendell seems to be doing everything he can to ensure that trend continues.

Movement to Abolish PA Legislature

I’m sympathetic to this guy’s plight, but I’m not sure it will really fix much in the long run.  The guy essentially argues that we ought to abolish the Pennsylvania Legislature, and replace it with a unicameral legislature, with fewer members who have fewer perks.

The problem of our legislature costing so much is a real one, but I’d prefer solving it by going to a part-time legislature, like Virginia has, and cutting some of the perks.  I doubt folks in Nebraska would agree a unicameral legislature is going to fix anything, and I would worry that a smaller legislature, where each state representative represents more people, will pay even less attention to constituents than the current one does.  By making them part time, it should cost less money, and reduce the amount of time they have to screw things up.