Here’s the segment 20/20 ran on the shooting incident:
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0MX3QtumSuE[/youtube]
Raise you hand if you carry a retention holster concealed at 1:00? No takers? But even with a good holster, from an active shooter point of view, that lecture hall is a death trap.
Guns aren’t magic devices that allow you to prevail against another armed person 100% of the time. Even a well trained police officer would have a difficult time drawing from concealment and firing in this situation, without taking a hit himself. I don’t feel too confident I would do all that much better than these kids. It’s a small, intimate lecture hall, some concealment but no good cover, and no way to easily move. 20/20s implication is that because there are some situations where a gun isn’t going to do you any good that there are no situations where a gun will do you any good. Let’s look back at the event that 20/20 exploited for this piece of journalistic garbage:
About halfway through class we heard the noises. Someone said something like, “It’s probably just construction.” The noises didn’t stop. The teacher stiffened up and said “That’s not what I think it is, is it?” That’s when I remember going into panic. I pointed at the teacher and said, “put that desk in front of the door, now.” She did it, and then said “someone call 911.” Colin to my right stood up and called 911.
At that point, the door was nudged open aggressively, and I saw a gun emerge into view. It was surreal. Following the gun was a man. He was Asian and had a lot of ammunition and gun gear on — like a big utility belt or something for ammo. That was the only glimpse I got. I quickly dove under a desk — that was the desk I chose to die under. He then began methodically and calmly shooting people down. It sounded rhythmic — like he took his time in between each shot and kept up the pace, moving from person to person. After every shot I thought, “OK, the next one is me.” Shot after shot went off and I never felt anything. I played dead and tried to look as lifeless as possible. Sometimes after a shot, I would hear a quick moan, or a slow one, or a grunt, or a quiet, reserved yell from one of the girls.
Let me ask you this, if you were in this situation, would you rather have a gun, or would you rather imagine yourself too stupid to use one, like 20/20 says you are? Would you rather be under a desk waiting to die? Would you feel safe with a cell phone in your hand, as 20/20 recommends, rather than a Glock?
I can’t help anyone who says they would rather be a sheep waiting for the slaughter, though I have no doubt some would, but I suspect most sensible people can see 20/20s assertion for the bullshit that is, and would see the utility of a gun in this situation.
UPDATE: Brillianter has more.